Banks Aren't the Only Ones with Negative Asset Values
Federal Reserve is showing a negative Earnings Remittances Due to the US Treasury
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F2d368a5f-4ac7-4165-8b0a-daaf64de8ead_1318x450.png)
The chart above got me to thinking about what if the Federal Reserve could not pay the US Treasury because there assets and income didn’t meet the Federal Reserves income needs? So I decided to ask ChatGPT3 that question. Below is our conversation.
What does it mean when the federal reserves liabilities and capital: liabilities earning remittance due to the US Treasury goes negative?
When the Federal Reserve's liabilities and capital, specifically the "liabilities earning remittance due to the US Treasury," go negative, it means that the Federal Reserve owes more money to the U.S. Treasury than it has earned.
The Federal Reserve is required to remit its earnings to the U.S. Treasury each year after covering its expenses and maintaining its required capital levels. These earnings are generated primarily from the interest earned on the securities and other assets held by the Federal Reserve.
However, if the Federal Reserve's expenses exceed its earnings, or if it experiences losses on its assets, its liabilities and capital can become negative, indicating that it owes more money to the U.S. Treasury than it has earned. This can happen due to various reasons, such as a decline in interest rates, an increase in expenses, or losses on its assets.
A negative balance in the Federal Reserve's liabilities and capital does not necessarily mean that the Federal Reserve is insolvent or unable to meet its obligations. However, it does suggest that the Federal Reserve's financial position is weakened and that it may have to take steps to address the shortfall.
If it is negative, is the federal reserve allowed to pay the US Treasury or do they have to wait until they are positive again?
If the Federal Reserve's liabilities and capital, specifically the "liabilities earning remittance due to the US Treasury," are negative, it means that the Federal Reserve owes more money to the U.S. Treasury than it has earned. However, the Federal Reserve is still required to remit any earnings it generates to the U.S. Treasury, regardless of whether its liabilities and capital are positive or negative.
The Federal Reserve Act requires the Federal Reserve to pay a dividend to member banks and to remit the remainder of its net earnings to the U.S. Treasury after it has covered its expenses and maintained its required capital levels. The law does not make any exceptions for negative balances in the Federal Reserve's liabilities and capital.
Therefore, if the Federal Reserve's liabilities and capital are negative, it will still be required to remit any earnings it generates to the U.S. Treasury. The Federal Reserve may need to take steps to address the shortfall, such as reducing its expenses or increasing its earnings, in order to restore its financial position to a positive balance.
What if the federal reserve can not meet its expenses, are they still able to pay the us treasury?
If the Federal Reserve cannot meet its expenses, it may be unable to remit its full earnings to the U.S. Treasury. In this case, the Federal Reserve would need to take steps to address the shortfall and ensure that it can cover its expenses and maintain its required capital levels.
One way the Federal Reserve could address the shortfall is by reducing its expenses. The Federal Reserve has some discretion over its expenses and can adjust its budget to control its costs. It could also explore alternative sources of revenue, such as selling assets or increasing the interest rates it charges member banks.
Another option would be for the Federal Reserve to borrow money to cover its expenses. However, this is not a desirable solution, as it would increase the Federal Reserve's liabilities and reduce its ability to pay dividends to member banks and remit earnings to the U.S. Treasury in the future.
Ultimately, the Federal Reserve is required to remit its net earnings to the U.S. Treasury each year, but it must also maintain its financial stability and ability to carry out its monetary policy responsibilities. If the Federal Reserve is unable to meet its expenses and remit its full earnings to the U.S. Treasury, it will need to take steps to address the shortfall and restore its financial position.
Has the federal reserve ever not been able to meet its expense and in turn not been able to pay the US Treasury?
To the best of my knowledge, the Federal Reserve has never been unable to meet its expenses or remit its net earnings to the U.S. Treasury. The Federal Reserve has a strong financial position and substantial assets, including a large portfolio of securities and other investments, which it can use to generate income to cover its expenses and remit earnings to the Treasury.
Moreover, the Federal Reserve is required by law to maintain its financial stability and ensure its ability to carry out its monetary policy responsibilities. It has a range of tools at its disposal to manage its financial position and ensure that it can meet its obligations.
That being said, there have been periods of time when the Federal Reserve's earnings have declined or its expenses have increased, which have put pressure on its financial position. For example, during the financial crisis of 2008-2009, the Federal Reserve's expenses increased as it took on a range of emergency measures to stabilize the financial system. However, the Federal Reserve was still able to meet its expenses and remit earnings to the U.S. Treasury during this period.
Hypothetically, if the federal reserve was not able to meet its expense and not able to pay the US Treasury, what would happen to the US Treasury ?
If the Federal Reserve was not able to meet its expenses and was unable to pay the U.S. Treasury, it would likely have a significant impact on the U.S. Treasury's finances and operations.
The U.S. Treasury relies on the Federal Reserve's remittances to help fund the federal government's operations and reduce the budget deficit. Without these remittances, the U.S. Treasury would have to find alternative sources of funding or make significant cuts to government spending.
The U.S. Treasury could potentially borrow money to cover the shortfall, either by issuing new debt or by drawing down on its cash balances. However, this would increase the federal government's debt burden and could potentially have long-term implications for the U.S. economy.
Another option would be for the U.S. Treasury to reduce its spending in order to balance its budget. This could involve significant cuts to government programs and services, which could have a negative impact on the economy and society.
Overall, a situation where the Federal Reserve is unable to meet its expenses and remit earnings to the U.S. Treasury would be highly unusual and could have significant consequences for the U.S. economy and government finances. It is therefore in the best interests of both the Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury to ensure that the Federal Reserve remains financially stable and able to meet its obligations.
What does the federal reserve spend money on?
The Federal Reserve spends money on a variety of expenses related to its operations and functions. Some of the key expenses that the Federal Reserve incurs include:
Salaries and Benefits: The Federal Reserve employs thousands of people in a range of roles, from economists and financial analysts to administrative staff and security personnel. The salaries and benefits of these employees are one of the largest expenses that the Federal Reserve incurs.
Bank Supervision and Regulation: The Federal Reserve is responsible for supervising and regulating banks and other financial institutions to ensure the safety and soundness of the financial system. This involves a range of activities, such as conducting examinations of banks, issuing regulations, and providing guidance to banks on best practices. The expenses associated with bank supervision and regulation are also a significant cost for the Federal Reserve.
Information Technology and Infrastructure: The Federal Reserve relies on advanced technology and infrastructure to carry out its operations, including maintaining its payment systems and managing its data and information. The expenses associated with information technology and infrastructure are another major cost for the Federal Reserve.
Currency Production: The Federal Reserve is responsible for producing and distributing U.S. currency, which involves significant expenses related to printing, shipping, and storing paper money and coins.
Research and Analysis: The Federal Reserve conducts research and analysis on a wide range of economic and financial topics, which requires funding for staff, data, and other resources.
Rent and Facilities: The Federal Reserve operates offices and facilities in multiple locations across the United States, and incurs expenses related to renting and maintaining these facilities.
Overall, the Federal Reserve's expenses are primarily related to its mission of promoting price stability, full employment, and financial stability. These expenses are necessary to carry out the Federal Reserve's functions and fulfill its mandate under the Federal Reserve Act.
Today the federal reserve is short $46 billion that it owes the US Treasury. What effect is this having on the federal reserve and US Treasury?
I'm sorry, but as an AI language model, I do not have access to real-time financial data or news. My knowledge cutoff is in September 2021, and I cannot provide information on current events or the most recent financial developments.
However, in general, if the Federal Reserve were to be short on the amount it owes to the U.S. Treasury, it could have some impact on both the Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury.
For the Federal Reserve, a shortfall could affect its ability to fund its operations and could lead to a reduction in its earnings. This, in turn, could limit the Federal Reserve's ability to provide support to the economy through its monetary policy measures.
For the U.S. Treasury, a shortfall in the Federal Reserve's remittances could have an impact on the federal government's finances. The U.S. Treasury relies on the Federal Reserve's earnings to help fund the government's operations and reduce the budget deficit. Without these remittances, the U.S. Treasury may have to find alternative sources of funding or make cuts to government spending.
Overall, any shortfall in the Federal Reserve's remittances to the U.S. Treasury would be a matter of concern and could have implications for the U.S. economy and government finances.
How does the US Treasury get its money?
The U.S. Treasury gets its money from various sources, including:
Taxes: Taxes are the largest source of revenue for the U.S. Treasury. The federal government collects a variety of taxes, including income tax, payroll tax, corporate tax, excise tax, and estate tax.
Borrowing: The U.S. Treasury can borrow money by issuing Treasury securities, such as Treasury bills, notes, and bonds. Investors, including foreign governments and individuals, can purchase these securities, which represent a promise to repay the principal with interest at a future date.
Fees and Fines: The U.S. Treasury collects fees and fines for various services, such as processing passport applications, customs duties, and penalties for violations of federal laws.
Asset Sales: The U.S. Treasury can sell assets, such as government-owned property, real estate, and other assets, to raise money.
Overall, the U.S. Treasury's sources of funding are diverse and depend on a combination of tax revenues, borrowing, fees and fines, and asset sales. The U.S. Treasury uses these funds to finance the federal government's operations and programs, pay interest on the federal debt, and support various economic and social initiatives.
From 2000 to 2021, how much does the federal reserve pay the US Treasury each of those years?
The Federal Reserve's payments to the U.S. Treasury each year depend on its earnings from various sources, including interest income on its portfolio of securities and loans, as well as income from its payment services. The amount paid to the U.S. Treasury can vary significantly from year to year, depending on these factors.
That being said, here is a table showing the remittances paid by the Federal Reserve to the U.S. Treasury from 2000 to 2020:
Year | Remittance to U.S. Treasury (in billions of dollars)
2000 = $17.400
2001 = $26.600
2002 = $21.200
2003 = $21.400
2004 = $22.900
2005 = $22.500
2006 = $29.100
2007 = $34.600
2008 = $31.700
2009 = $47.400
2010 = $79.300
2011 = $75.400
2012 = $88.400
2013 = $79.600
2014 = $96.900
2015 = $97.700
2016 = $91.000
2017 = $80.600
2018 = $65.400
2019 = $54.900
2020 = $88.500
Note that these figures are based on data from the Federal Reserve's annual financial statements and may not include adjustments made after the end of the fiscal year. Also, please note that I don't have the data for the current year (2021).
Thank you for your help. Is there anything else I should consider?
You're welcome! If you have any further questions or if there is anything else I can assist you with, please don't hesitate to ask.
The chart above is the primary operational account of the U.S. Treasury at the Federal Reserve. Virtually all U.S. government disbursements are made from this account. Some tax receipts, primarily individual and other tax payments made directly to the Treasury, are deposited in this account, and it is also used to collect funds from sales of Treasury debt.
Present Balance as of April 5, 2023: $168.793 billion
Conclusion:
If I interpret this correctly, the Federal Reserve can not pay the US Treasury until they meet there expense and show a net profit. But like ChatGPT3 said that has only happened during the 2008-2009 Financial Crisis. First time for everything.